I've caught this at Safeway, Kroger, Target, Walmart, BJ's, Costco, and Sam's Club. It's not one store's tactic. It's industry-wide.
Two examples from my own cart:
Razors. A pack that was $19.99 got bumped to $22.99, but coordinated with a sale that temporarily dropped the price to $15.99. That reads like a 30% ($7) savings off the new price. The regular price actually went up 15% ($3). This one's a genuine deal, the sale price beats even the old $19.99, but it's still a limited-time window built to bury a sizeable price increase under a big percentage-off number. Once the sale ends, you're back to a shelf price that's 15% higher than it used to be.
Seltzer. A private label 12 pack went from $4.29 to $4.49, a 5% increase, coordinated with a buy-two-for-$8 promotion, which works out to $4.00 each. Technically below $4.49. Barely below the $4.29 I was paying before, and it took buying two to get there.
Why it works. A couple psychological marketing tactics at play here:
- The "you saved $X" math is always calculated against the new, inflated price, not the price you actually remember paying. A bigger printed discount triggers a stronger response than the truthful one underneath it.
- Most people don't carry exact prices in their head from a month or two ago. Stores are counting on that. By the next time you buy the item, they're hoping you'll forget the old price and settle into the new, higher one as the norm.
None of this requires a conspiracy. It's standard retail pricing psychology, applied consistently enough to become a pattern once you're watching for it.
What I do about it. Two things. First, I try to notice and compare the before-and-after non-sale prices, so I know what the actual price is changing to. Second, I determine if the sale is good enough to stock up before I have to pay the new higher price next time. The goal is to buy enough at the sale price to push off paying the new regular price for as long as possible. Beware though, overbuying just trades one cost (full price) for another (waste, clutter), so it's a balance.
If you've spotted this pattern somewhere else, leave your own examples in the comments section below. Right now it seems to be everywhere.

Comments
Post a Comment